Wednesday, May 30, 2012

Photo Essay Results



Meh.

Seriously "meh."

I have to say I'm not really happy with the way this essay went.  Some good writing and some interesting photos, but very few of you wrote the essay according to the prompt.  Even after discussing the essay further in class, and making it clear that the essay should to be a ABOUT a photo (and not just an essay WITH a photo), most of you still went ahead and wrote a plain old reflective essay.

Some of you wrote exactly what I asked (Dohyun, Namdo, Jiyoon, Seungmin, Yoojin, Yunjo, Sungeun most of all - in descending order.  Dohyun and Nambo the only ones who nailed it).

So, almost everyone should rewrite it if they haven't already (either for content or the grammatical stuff).  I'm being generous with the grades below, but most of you should be getting B's simply for missing the point of the prompt or sloppy grammar or being super late. :)



Mewtwo
92.0
 
Blastoise
92.0
 
Lugia
92.0
 
Dragonite
92.0
 
Rayquaza
92.5
 
Zapdos
92.5
 
Tyranitar
92.0
 
Arcanine
91.5
 
Ho-Oh
90.0
 
Venusaur
93.0
 
Gengar
92.0
 
Raikou
77.0
 
Kyogre
93.5
 
Snorlax
93.0
 
Alakazam
94.0
 
Scizor
80.0
 

Wednesday, May 16, 2012

Is this brillant or is this brilliant?

From the oatmeal blog (which proves blogs can make you money and be super awesome):



Walmart Essays and scores: Epilogue

FOR YOUR INTEREST - Assuming it exists...

Forbes Magazine has listed Walmart CEO, Mike Duke, as the third worst CEO of a large corporation.  Walmart stock value has plateaued since he took over for Lee Scott, and Walmart hasn't kept up with on-line retailers who are innovating the home shopping experience.  Read more IF you are interested:


Moving on...

With midterms and AP, we really haven't had a "real" opportunity to move forward and get some writing done.  But I think the time was valuable and used for various drafts of your Walmart essays.  Initially, I gave more than half of the class a B, and many of you worked hard to move to an A by focusing more on MLA.  However, there still hasn't been one student to master it perfectly.  We will have one more try at this, which brings me to a main problem:

BIG WEAKNESS:  The majority of students in this class do not read the fine print Following directions (posted permanently here on the blog so nothing gets lost) as closely  as possible will easily add valuable points to your scores, especially when you get to university.  Yes, you guys are very very very busy, and always multitasking. BUT do not rush to get things done without meditating on the task fully.  Read ALL of the directions. Think of it as reading a map before you get in the car.  Get things right the first time.  Analyze the prompt.  Know what MLA is. Read about Walmart. This also applies to the photo essay, which only a couple of students seem to have understood.

As you know, I expected an online version of the Walmart essay, as well as the MLA formatted hard copy.  If you didn't get the results you wanted it may be due to following oversights:

  • Not MLA.  MLA can't be taught.  You have to learn it yourself by looking at it through the Purdue website, which I've posted a few times:                                                          http://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/747/01/
  • Online version not updated with links, pictures, grammatical errors cleaned up.
Walmart is gone with the wind, so here are the final grades for that AND the rest of your other grades, so you know where you are at.  Right now, we have fulfilled 52% of our total, not counting 25% for the exam (which will be very difficult).  So we have another 23% to play with.  This will include one more synthesis essay, with the rest contributed to a class participation score.  Class Participation includes overall blog content, comments left, and in-class participation (i.e. do you stare at your laptop too much).   


Wednesday, May 2, 2012

A Picture Speaks a Thousand Words - Photo Essay

UPDATE and REMINDER: Make sure your essay is about the photo - at least in the intro and conclusion. Address the photo and interact with what's in it.  Bring the reader to the moment that it was taken - and then launch into the story behind it.  The best essays will focus on just one photo, and will not be able to be read unless the photo is there with the essay. If the reader can read your essay without the photo, you might be straying from the prompt.

Due Date:  Again, I'm flexible since it is AP time.  Get it done before AP is over, and bonus points for those who got it done by the original date.  If you wrote it and maybe didn't follow the prompt that closely (75% of you :) you can write a new one and have at least one "extra blog post" taken care of.:)

This assignment should be relatively easy for you to write, so I'd like it to be completed between now and AP exams. I actually felt compelled to write my own version of this assignment, and enjoyed the experience quite a bit. It was easy to think of a meaningful photo, and it didn't take long at all to bang out 5 paragraphs. So what should you write? It's up to you.  You can approach this assignment any way you see fit.  I'd like you to be creative, and write in an accessible tone that is reflective, analytical, and maybe even poetic at times. There's the old saying that "a picture speaks a thousand words."  For this, I think you should only need about 500.  Let's say at least 500.  To get there, you can consider the 5 W's. For example:

  • Who's in the picture? Family? Friends? No one?  A dog?
  • What's unique about it?  Is there a story behind it?  What does it mean to you personally? What do you think about it when you look at it?
  • When did you take it?  What kind of person were you at that time?  How have things changed? 
  • Where did you take it? What does that place mean to you? 
  • Why did you take it?  Why do you like it?  Why is it good?
  • How would you describe it poetically? Etc. etc. etc.

Things you should focus on, which I will take into consideration when grading:

  • Organized paragraphs.  Every paragraph should have a unique function, and fulfill that intent before progressing to the next paragraph. Try and hop from one stepping stone to the next gracefully with proper transitions.  
  • Avoid Repetition.  Make sure you aren't over emphasizing the subject of your sentence or paragraph with repeated mentions of a noun. This was a problem with the Walmart essay, where the word Walmart was used to explain the drawback of Walmart, in order to reveal the postive aspects of Walmart and the harmful aspects of Walmart.  Make sure your sentences are concise and to the point, and don't fill the essay up with filler.  
  • Connect your intro and conclusion, and have a strong theme.   

Please don't feel you need to answer all or any of the 5 W's, and please don't use what I wrote as a template.  It's not important to discuss the camera you used or the technical details of photography, but if you are into that - cool.  The real purpose of the essay is to explore "reflection" with a visual prompt.  The photo doesn't even need to be one that you've taken personally.  You can even be in the photo.  Or maybe it's simply a photo you really admire or love.  It can be really old, or even really new - taken for the exact reason to write this essay. You can write descriptively with a bit more emotional/personal depth than you otherwise would in a Walmart essay.  I'd also like you to provide a title for your photo - which is what most professional artists do with their work.  Here's mine:

Steps
 


I've taken thousands of pictures over the years, but didn't invest in a "serious camera" until a  photographer friend of mine commented on the photo above.  He didn't believe me when I told him I'd taken it with a 5.1 Megapixel Sony Cybershot, and he said a simple "point and shoot" had no business capturing what it did.   So, at least in my eyes, the above photo has some magical quality to it.  Two monks ascend a granite stairway into the foggy heavens of Mount Taishan, and despite hoards of Chinese tourists wearing matching red hats about to swarm into the shot - I was able to click the button at just the right second and preserve a bit of perfection.  Oriental romanticism perhaps.

My romance began in the third grade.  My teacher, Mrs. Crandle, always traveled during summer vacations, and after returning from Japan she taught us all about the unique social customs.  In my mind, there could be no place on earth as alien.  I imagined myself flying off to Tokyo to learn ninja skills from a wise sensei, drinking tea while sharpening a samurai sword beneath cherry blossoms.  I made it my goal in life to someday journey there, and when I found out later that I could teach English as a means of a "working holiday," I sort of knew where I'd end up after university.

Twenty five years later, I'm not in Japan, and the "working holiday" is kind of serious. I'm in Korea, where I've immersed myself into a unique culture, marrying myself into a kind Korean family, working at a world class Korean high school.  Korea is my home, and I'm happy to wake up every morning and dress up in Korean traditional clothing, and then go to work where there's even the odd traditional Korean building, where I eat traditional Korean food.  I don't get to train with ninjas or hang out with a kungfu master, but I get to spend time with amazing students.  My life hasn't included lofty ambitions such as becoming president or walking on the moon, but when I look at the picture above, I feel I've somehow realized a practical childhood dream.  But it did take a while to get here.

Traditionally, those who climb Taishan seek "sunrise, birth, and renewal." To reach the top, one must climb precisely 7,200 steps.  Following those monks, I climbed them in 2007, after climbing three of the other "Five Great Mountains" in 2005.  If China had become my backyard playground, Korea had become my home away from home over the course of 5 years - where I'd work, save money, and then get on a boat to head back to China. Or maybe a plane to SE Asia. Or maybe Europe. Sometimes I'd travel for a month before going back.  Sometimes for three.  On my longest journey, I spent almost a year venturing from Korea to the southern tip of India, without boarding a single airplane.  Most of the time I was alone, and the only earthly possessions I owned were a backpack, clothes, an iPod and a camera.   Sometimes it was sad, and I wondered what the point of all this wandering was.  To take pictures?  

Photoshopped  to be black and white, the monks are actually holding bright red plastic bags full of vegetables.  I might have also cropped it to exclude an elbow or two, as there were thousands of other tourists who were also making the pilgrimage.  I recall getting food poisoning from some dumplings I ate at the top, and I remember having to pay double for a place to sleep because I wasn't Chinese.  Oriental romanticism isn't always an ideal that's easy to maintain, but those two monks, climbing carefully up those solid steps towards a holier place - they mean a lot to me.

In life, we have to keep on climbing.